8 Best Substitutes for Olives – Top Alternatives to Use Instead

Do you love olives but don’t eat them because of a food allergy? Or maybe you’re just looking for a new flavor to add to your dish? Whatever the reason, we’ve got you covered.

Olives are a type of fruit that is often used in cooking. They have a slightly bitter taste and are usually eaten pickled or preserved. Olives are a good source of vitamins and minerals, and they can also be used to make olive oil.

In this blog post, we’ll list some of the best substitutes for olives. We’ll explain the differences and similarities between each one and olives, and give you tips on how to use them in your recipes. Let’s get started!

List Of Substitutes For Olives:

  1. Capers
  2. Artichoke Hearts
  3. Pickled Peppers
  4. Mushrooms
  5. Anchovies
  6. Pickled Tomato
  7. Pickled Onions
  8. Blue Cheese


Olives and capers are both common ingredients in Mediterranean cuisine. Olives are prized for their distinct mild, salty flavor, while capers add a pop of tartness to dishes. However, olives can be quite pricy, and they may not be available at your local grocery store.

In casual situations, capers make an excellent substitute for olives. They can be used in a variety of dishes, including pasta salads, and pizzas. Best of all, capers are usually less expensive than olives and can often be found in the condiment aisle of your local supermarket.

Artichoke Hearts

If you’re in a pinch and need an olive substitute for your recipe, look no further than the artichoke heart.

While not an exact match in terms of flavor, artichoke hearts can be used in a variety of casual dishes where olives would typically be used.

For example, try throwing a few artichoke hearts into your next batch of homemade pasta sauce or top your pizza with them instead of olives.

Artichoke hearts are also a great addition to spinach dip or hummus.

Pickled Peppers

If you’re looking to add a flavorful punch to a salad or pasta dish, swap out the olives for some diced pickled peppers.

The acidity of the peppers will brighten up the flavors of the other ingredients, and their crunch will add texture.

You can also use pickled peppers as a topping for pizza or bruschetta in place of olives


If you’re looking for a casual substitute for olives, mushrooms are a great option.

While they don’t have the same intense flavor, mushrooms can add a nice earthy depth to dishes.

Plus, they’re versatile and easy to find. You can use them in everything from salads to pasta dishes. Just be sure to chop them up into small pieces so they blend in with the other ingredients.


While olives and anchovies may seem like completely different ingredients, they can be used as substitutes for each other in some cases.

This is because both olives and anchovies are salty and have a strong flavor, making them ideal for adding a bit of depth to a dish. Anchovies can be substituted for olives in any recipe that calls for chopped or sliced olives.

They can also be used as a topping for pizzas or salads in place of olive chunks or slices. While the flavors of olives and anchovies are not identical, they are similar enough that anchovies can be used as a casual substitute in many dishes.

Pickled Tomato

Whether you’re putting together a simple dish like pasta salad or something more complex like chicken piccata, these bite-sized snacks pack a flavorful punch.

Best of all, they’re usually much cheaper than olives and can be found in most grocery stores.

So next time you’re in the mood for something salty and tangy, reach for a jar of pickled tomatoes instead of olives. You may just find that they’re your new favorite ingredient.

Pickled Onions

Pickled onions can make an excellent substitute for olives. Not only are they much cheaper, but their slightly sweet and tangy flavor can help to brighten up a dish.

Additionally, pickled onions are much easier to prepare than olives, as there is no need to remove the pits. As a result, they can be a great way to add flavor and color to a dish without breaking the bank.

Blue Cheese

Blue cheese is a pungent, flavorful cheese that can be used as a substitute for olives in certain dishes. While it may not have the same level of sweetness as olives, blue cheese can add a nice salty flavor to salads and sandwiches.

In addition, blue cheese has a creamier texture than olives, which can make it a more pleasant addition to some dishes.

Overall, blue cheese is a versatile ingredient that can be used in place of olives in many recipes.

FAQs About Olive Substitutes

Q. What is a good substitute for Kalamata olives?

A.There are many substitutes for olives that can add flavor to a dish. Some of the most popular substitutes include artichoke hearts, mushrooms, pickled peppers, and pickled carrots. Each of these ingredients has a unique flavor that can enhance the taste of a dish.

Q. Can you replace black olives with green?

A. Yes, you can replace black olives with green olives in most recipes. The flavors of the two olives are similar enough that they can be used interchangeably. However, green olives tend to be a bit saltier than black olives, so you may need to adjust the seasoning of your dish accordingly.

Q. What can I use instead of olives in a martini?

A. There are many substitutes for olives in a martini. You can use pimento-stuffed olives, kalamata olives, or any other type of olive that you prefer.

Q. Can I use pickle juice instead of olive juice in a martini?

A. Yes, you can use pickle juice instead of olive juice in a martini.


When it comes to substitutes for olives, there are plenty of options to choose from. Whether you’re looking for a substitution that tastes the same or one that has a similar texture, we’ve got you covered. With this comprehensive guide, you can easily swap out olives for a comparable substitute in your favorite recipes. Have fun experimenting and find the perfect substitution for your next dish!