8 Substitutes for Peppadew Pepper: Best Alternatives

What do you do when peppadew peppers aren’t available?

This is something that a number of persons might be asking, especially during the off-season.

Luckily, several substitutes can be used to replicate the peppadew flavor. Check out this blog as we explore a few of the best substitutes for peppadew peppers.

We’ll provide the ratios needed for substitution and give some examples of recipes where these substitutes can be used!

Here’s what I mean.

Substitutes for Peppadew Peppers

  1. Sweety drop peppers
  2. Pepperoncini
  3. Rocoto chiles
  4. Sweet cherry peppers
  5. Giardiniera
  6. Sweet red pepper
  7. Pickled jalapenos
  8. Pimentos

Sweety drop peppers

Sweety drop peppers offer a great sweet flavor with mild heat, making them a perfect substitute for Peppadews.

These peppers can be pickled and used as a sweet condiment on sandwiches or as a 1-to-1 ratio replacement for the Peppadew pepper in many dishes.

The mild heat of Sweety drop peppers is great for those who do not want the spicy flavor of the Peppadew pepper.

Plus, they are just as easy to find and usually less expensive.


If you’re looking for a tangy, bright flavor to add to your dishes, pepperoncini is a great substitute for Peppadew pepper.

These little neon green peppers pack a punch and can be used in a 1:1 ratio to replace Peppadew peppers in any recipe.

They’re a popular topping on pizza and salads, and their tangy flavor is sure to brighten up any dish. Plus, they have a soft heat that makes them perfect for those who don’t like things too spicy.

Rocoto chiles

A great alternative to the Peppadew pepper is Rocoto chili. This chili is very spicy, so you’ll need to use half as much as you would with a Peppadew.

The Rocoto chili also has a great citrus taste that can really brighten up a dish. And the nice thing about using a Rocoto chili as a substitute is that it will add a great pop of color to your dish.

One great way to use Rocoto chilies as a substitute for Peppadew peppers is in a stir-fry. Simply add them in along with your other vegetables and cook until they’re tender.

The Rocoto chili will give your stir-fry a great kick of heat and flavor.

Another great option is to use them in place of Peppadew peppers in a salsa. Just chop them up and add them to your salsa recipe.

They’ll give it a nice spicy kick that will really wake up your taste buds.

Sweet cherry peppers

I am always looking for perfect substitutes in the kitchen.

And when it comes to peppers, I have found that sweet cherry peppers are the perfect substitute for Peppadew Pepper.

You can use them in a 1-to-1 ratio, and they are great stuffed or in pasta dishes. The flavor is comparable, and they have a bit of sweetness that takes the dish to the next level.


Giardiniera is a canned vegetable mix that includes peppers, onions, carrots, and celery.

It’s tart and sweet, making it a great addition to salsa or other dishes.

Likewise, you can put them on sandwiches and burgers, of course!

Best of all, it can be used as a 1-to-1 replacement for Peppadew peppers.

Pickled jalapenos

As a chef, I’m always looking for ways to add a little spice to my dishes. That’s why I was excited to discover that pickled jalapenos make a great substitute for Peppadew peppers.

Like Peppadews, they have a sweet and sour taste that mirrors the flavor of the peppers perfectly.

And because they’re already pickled, they’re a great add-on to nachos or mixed in with johnnycakes.

Best of all, they’re usually much cheaper than their Peppadew counterparts.


Pimentos and Peppadew peppers are extremely alike. In fact, due to their red color, many people believe that they are the same pepper.

However, there are some subtle differences between the two.

Pimentos are typically a bit less sweet than Peppadews, so honey may be added to resolve this.

They also tend to be a bit milder, making them a good choice for those who don’t like their food too spicy. When it comes to cooking with these peppers, they can be used interchangeably using a 1-to-1 ratio.

Both are great diced onto pizza or tossed into salads.


What does a Peppadew pepper taste like?

Peppadew peppers taste like a cross between sweet peppers and chili peppers.

They have a fruity flavor with a hint of heat.

Can I substitute another pepper for a Peppadew?

Yes, several peppers can be used as substitutes for Peppadew peppers. Some good options include pepperoncini, sweet cherry peppers

Are sweet cherry peppers the same as Peppadew peppers?

No, sweet cherry peppers are not the same as Peppadew peppers. They are similar in flavor, but sweet cherry peppers are typically a bit sweeter than Peppadew peppers.

What is the best substitute for Peppadew pepper?

The best substitutes for Peppadew peppers include Rocoto chili, sweet cherry peppers, Giardiniera, pickled jalapenos, and Pimentos.

Each of these peppers has a similar flavor to Peppadew peppers and can be used in a variety of dishes.

What is the difference between Peppadew peppers and other peppers?

Peppadew peppers are a type of chili pepper that is grown in South Africa. They are sweet with a slight heat, and their flavor has been described as a cross between a sweet pepper and chili pepper.

Other peppers, such as bell peppers, are not as sweet and do not have the same level of heat.

In Summary

Peppadew peppers are a type of chili pepper that is sweeter and milder than most other chili peppers. They are often used as a substitute for sweet bell peppers or roasted red peppers.

Other popular substitutes for Peppadew peppers include Rocoto chili, sweet cherry peppers, Giardiniera, pickled jalapenos, and Pimentos. Each of these peppers has a similar flavor to Peppadew peppers and can be used in a variety of dishes.

Do you have any other suggestions for substitutes for Peppadew peppers?

Let us know in the comments below!

And don’t forget to check out our other blog posts for more tips and tricks on cooking with peppers.