11 Substitutes for Rotel Tomatoes (#3 Is The Best)

Rotel is a popular brand of processed tomatoes and green chilies that is used in many Tex-Mex dishes.

So, looking for Rotel Tomatoes substitutes? You’re in luck! In this article, we will provide you with a list of 11 flavors that you can use as a replacement.

We will explain the differences and similarities between each flavor, and give you the exact ratios to use when substituting.

Let’s get started!

Substitutes for Rotel Tomatoes:

  1. Canned diced tomatoes
  2. Tomato puree
  3. Fresh tomatoes
  4. Salsa
  5. Lemon pickles
  6. Green chilies
  7. Tomato ketchup
  8. Marinara sauce
  9. Picante sauce
  10. Enchilada sauce
  11. Homemade rotel

Canned diced tomatoes

If you’re looking for an ideal substitute for Rotel tomatoes, then look no further than canned diced tomatoes. They are easy to store and find.

When it comes to taste, they’re a perfect replacement for Rotel tomatoes. However, when using canned diced tomatoes in soups, blend them for better consistency.

So if you’re looking for an alternative that’s just as delicious, try using canned diced tomatoes instead. You won’t be disappointed.

Fresh tomatoes

In many cases, fresh tomatoes can be used as a substitute for Rotel tomatoes.

Some benefits of using fresh tomatoes include that they are healthy and easy to find. You can also chop them beforehand for ease.

Another benefit is that fresh tomatoes provide a more authentic flavor to your dish. However, when using fresh tomatoes, it is important to note that they may not be as easy to track down during winter.

Additionally, they may not have the same level of acidity as Rotel tomatoes. As a result, you may need to add a few ingredients to make the dish taste to your preferences.

Tomato puree

For those who are healthy and looking for an easy way to get their daily vitamins and minerals, tomatoes are a great option. However, not everyone enjoys the taste of fresh tomatoes or the texture of cooked ones.

This is where tomato puree is a perfect substitute for Rotel tomatoes and other cooked tomato products. Not only is it healthy, but it is also filled with vitamins and minerals that are essential for the body.

In addition, it is very easy to make at home and cooks easily. As a result, it is a great option for those who are looking for a healthy alternative to cooked tomatoes.

Lastly, tomato puree works great with soups, stews, curries, and sauces.


Salsa is a great substitute for Rotel tomatoes because it is best for Mexican dishes. It is ready to use and adds extra flavor. You can also use it as a replacement in different cases.

The benefits of using the substitute are that you don’t have to worry about acidity, and it also has a longer shelf life. Additionally, salsa adds an extra layer of flavor to dishes, making them more exciting and delicious.

So if you’re looking for a way to spice up your cooking, salsa is the perfect solution.

Lemon pickles

Lemon pickles are a zesty and tangy addition to any dish. And they can add extra flavor when used as a replacement for Rotel tomatoes.

The vinegary taste profile of lemon pickles can be a strong contrast to the sweetness of tomatoes. But the acidity can also help to brighten up a dish.

In addition, lemon pickles are an excellent source of vitamin C, which can help to boost the immune system.

When substituting lemon pickles for Rotel tomatoes, it is important to keep in mind that the pickles will add a crunchy texture to the dish. For this reason, they are best used as a topping or garnish rather than as the main ingredient.

Lastly, pickled lemons have a very strong flavor. So, use them in moderation.

Green chilies

Try green chilies if you’re in a pinch and need a unique but good substitute for Rotel tomatoes! They add hotness and extra flavor to any dish. But you’ll probably want to use less than you would Rotel tomatoes since they pack quite the punch.

You might not think that green chilies would be a good replacement for something like tomatoes. But trust me – it works!

Next time you’re in the middle of making a dish and realize you’re out of Rotel tomatoes, don’t panic!. Instead, just grab some green chilies and give them a try. I promise you won’t be disappointed.

Tomato ketchup

Tangy and sweet, with just the right amount of spice. tomato ketchup is a versatile condiment that goes well with everything. Ketchup makes everything taste better, from salsa to nachos to burgers and fries.

And, as it turns out, it can also be used as a substitute for Rotel tomatoes. When cooked down, the ketchup provides a similar Tangy and sweet taste—with just the right amount of spice, making it an ideal replacement for canned tomatoes.

Plus, ketchup is less likely to cause stomach upsets than its spicier cousin. So next time you’re in a pinch, reach for the ketchup instead of the Rotel tomatoes. You might just be surprised at how well it works.

However, be cautious when using ketchup. Due to its sweet taste profile, it can easily make your dish taste different. So, use it in moderation.

Marinara sauce

Marinara sauce is a tomato-based sauce that is typically used on pasta dishes. However, it can also be used as a substitute for Rotel tomatoes.

The best cases to use this substitute are when making lasagna or fajitas. This is because the marinara sauce will add extra flavor to the dish.

When substituting, use a 1:1 ratio. For example, if a recipe calls for one cup of Rotel tomatoes, use one cup of marinara sauce instead.

While this substitution may not work for all dishes, it is a great way to add extra flavor to your favorite recipes.

Picante sauce

Texan tomato-based sauce, or Picante sauce, can be used as a substitute for Rotel tomatoes. This is because it already contains the Tex-Mex seasoning that is often used in sauces and tacos.

In addition, it can help to add a Tex-Mex flavor to dishes without the need for additional spices. However, it is important to note that Picante sauce is generally more expensive than canned tomatoes.

As a result, it may not be the best choice for those on a budget. Nonetheless, Picante sauce can be a great way to add Tex-Mex flavor to your favorite recipes.

Enchilada sauce

Enchilada sauce can be used as a substitute for Rotel tomatoes. This is because it has a similar consistency and can be used in tacos.

It is also hot and spicy, making it a good option for those who like their food to have a bit of a kick. To substitute the enchilada sauce for Rotel tomatoes, use a 1:1 ratio. This means that for every one cup of Rotel tomatoes, you will need one cup of enchilada sauce.

When it comes to enchiladas, this substitution is best made with red enchilada sauce. This will give the dish the same flavor profile as if you had used Rotel tomatoes.

While there are other substitutes that can be used in place of Rotel tomatoes, enchilada sauce is the best option when making enchiladas.

However, you would need to spice down your overall recipe. Because the enchilada sauce already contains spices.

Homemade Rotel

So, none of the Rotel tomato substitutes caught your attention. Don’t worry, just make the Rotel tomatoes at home.

To make Rotel tomatoes, you will need:

  • Two parts peeled and diced Roma tomatoes
  • 1 part Habanero chili peppers or roasted Anaheim
  • Black pepper to taste
  • Splash of lemon juice
  • 1-2 tsp dried oregano
  • 1-2 tsp coriander
  • Salt and pepper to taste

Mix all of these ingredients well and store them in an airtight container. The homemade Rotel tomatoes can last from 1 to 2 months. However, you will need to store them at a low temperature to preserve their fresh taste.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can salsa be used as a Rotel tomato substitute?

Yes, salsa can be used as a Rotel tomato substitute. Both salsa and Rotel tomatoes mainly consist of tomatoes. This gives them a similar taste.

However, salsa contains different spices than Rotel tomatoes. So, when using salsa as a Rotel tomato substitute, balance out the spices to make your recipe taste better.

Moreover, the spiciness of salsa can vary from brand to brand. So, it is better to taste the salsa before putting it in your dish.

What is a Ro-tel tomato?

Ro-tel or Rotel tomato is a Texas-based tomato blend. As the name suggests, this blend consists mainly of tomatoes. But it also contains chilies which make it taste both tangy and spicy at the same time.

It is usually used in sauces and dips to give the dish a better flavor. Some people also use it in tacos and nachos to make them spicier.

What is the difference between diced tomatoes and Ro-tel tomatoes?

Most people mistake Rotel tomatoes for simple canned diced tomatoes. But both of these ingredients have huge differences.

Canned diced tomatoes, as their name suggests, are diced tomatoes in a can. Due to the brine, these canned tomatoes stay edible for a long time.

On the other hand, Rotel tomatoes are a tomato, chili, and spice blend. Therefore, Rotel tomatoes have a deeper and spicier taste profile than canned diced tomatoes.

These two ingredients can be used interchangeably with a little bit of extra work. So, if you are using diced tomatoes instead of Ro-tel tomatoes, it is better to add extra spice to get the same flavor

On the other hand, if you are substituting Rotel tomatoes for diced one, lessen the spice. This will ensure that the dish does not get too hot.

In conclusion

Substituting Rotel tomatoes is not as hard as it may seem. There are many options available that can be used as a replacement.

The best substitutes for Rotel tomatoes are enchilada sauce, salsa, and diced tomatoes. However, you will need to adjust your recipe if you use any of these rotel alternatives.