12 Best Substitutes for Apple Jelly You Can Find Easily

Apple jelly is a popular condiment that can be used in many different recipes.

However, what do you do if you can’t find apple jelly or don’t have any on hand?

There are many substitutes that you can use to replace apple jelly in your recipes.

In this article, we will discuss the best apple jelly substitutes. We’ll also give examples of how to use these substitutes in your recipes!

Let’s start!

Substitutes for Apple Jelly

  1. Pear Fruit Jam
  2. Apricot Jam
  3. Raspberry Jam
  4. Strawberry Jelly
  5. Peach Jam
  6. Marmalade
  7. Orange Jam
  8. Honey
  9. Apple Sauce
  10. Grape Jelly
  11. Canned Peaches
  12. Apple Juice

Pear Fruit Jam

Pear fruit jam is an excellent substitute for apple jelly. It has a similar sweetness and consistency, making it ideal for use in baked goods and other recipes.

Additionally, pear fruit jam is packed with nutrients and antioxidants, making it a healthier option than other types of jelly.

Apricot Jam

Apricot jam can be used as a substitute for apple jelly in many recipes. The sweetness of the apricots helps to offset the tartness of apples, while the smooth texture of the jam makes it a perfect spread for toast or biscuits.

In addition, apricot jam can also be used as a filling for pies or tarts. The subtle flavor of the fruit goes well with both savory and sweet dishes, making it a versatile ingredient for any kitchen.

When substituting apricot jam for apple jelly, it is important to keep in mind that the jam will add a slightly different flavor to the dish.

Raspberry Jam

Raspberry jam makes for an excellent substitute for apple jelly. Here are some cases where you can use raspberry jam in place of apple jelly:

  • When making PB&Js: the sweetness of the raspberries will complement the peanut butter perfectly.
  • In baked goods: raspberry jam can be used in any recipe that calls for apple jelly, from pies to tarts to turnovers.
  • As a glaze: for meat or vegetables, a thin layer of raspberry jam is a delicious way to add some extra flavor (and color!).

Raspberry jam is also a great option because it is usually less expensive than apple jelly, and it can be easily found in most grocery stores.

And while there will be a slight change in flavor when using raspberry jam instead of apple jelly, the overall taste will be just as delicious.

Strawberry Jelly

Some people may not know this, but strawberry jelly can be used as a replacement for apple jelly in many recipes.

There are multiple benefits of using the substitute, such as the fact that it is usually less expensive and easier to find in stores.

In addition, strawberry jelly has a similar texture and consistency to apple jelly, so it will not change the recipe too much.

The substitute is also suitable for many different recipes, such as pies and tarts.

However, there are some things to keep in mind when using strawberry jelly as a substitute for apple jelly.

For example, the flavor of the dish will be slightly different since strawberries are naturally sweeter than apples.

In addition, the color of the dish will also be affected, as strawberry jelly is usually a lighter pink color than apple jelly.

Peach Jam

There are many reasons why you might want to substitute peach jam for apple jelly in a recipe.

For one thing, peach jam is generally less expensive than apple jelly. Additionally, peach jam is often easier to find in stores than apple jelly. And, of course, peach jam can add a unique flavor to any dish.

One great way to use peach jam as a substitute for apple jelly is in a grilled cheese sandwich.

The sweetness of the peach jam pairs perfectly with the savory flavors of the cheese and bread.

Plus, the jam will help to soften the bread and make it more cohesive.

Another delicious way to use peach jam is in a PB&J sandwich. The familiar flavors of peanut butter and jelly are enhanced by the addition of peaches.

And, like with grilled cheese, the jam will help to soften the bread.


Though apple jelly and marmalade both preserve the tart, bright flavor of the fruit, they differ in their ingredients and textural properties.

Apple jelly is made with only fruit juice and sugar, while marmalade always includes the peel and pulp of the fruit as well.

This difference alters not only the appearance but also the mouthfeel and subtle flavor of each product.

In general, apple jelly will be glossy and smooth with a purer taste of apples, while marmalade will be more opaque with a riper flavor and coarser texture due to the presence of fruit peel.

As a result, these two preserves can be used interchangeably in many recipes that call for one or the other.

Apple jelly can be used as a Marmalade-like spread on toast or added to glazes or sauces for pork or poultry.

Conversely, Marmalade can be stirred into yogurt or oatmeal for a quick breakfast or used as an Apple jelly-like filling for cakes or pastries.

Orange Jam

Orange jam makes an excellent substitute for apple jelly in most recipes.

It has a similar sweetness and acidity, and it pairs well with other ingredients like cinnamon and nutmeg.

Plus, orange jam is easy to find and relatively inexpensive.


Honey has a similar sweetness and viscosity as apple jelly, making it a perfect replacement in any recipe.

In addition, honey is rich in nutrients and has anti-inflammatory and antibacterial properties.

As a result, it can be healthier than apple jelly. While honey may change the flavor of some recipes slightly, it is generally a suitable replacement for apple jelly in most cases.

When substituting honey for apple jelly, take into consideration that honey has a much more liquid-like texture than apple jelly.

Apple Sauce

Apple sauce is a great substitute for apple jelly in many recipes. It has a similar texture and flavor but is much easier to make at home. Plus, it doesn’t contain any added sugar or preservatives.

You can use apple sauce as a replacement for apple jelly in pies, tarts, and other desserts. It’s also delicious on pancakes and waffles.

If you’re looking for a healthy alternative to store-bought jam, apple sauce is a great choice.

It’s lower in sugar and calories and contains more fiber and vitamins than most commercial jams.

When substituting apple sauce for jelly in recipes, you may need to add a little extra liquid to compensate for the lack of water in the sauce.

Related Questions

What’s the difference between apple jelly and apple butter?

Apple jelly is made from fruit juice, while apple butter is made from cooked apples. Apple jelly has a smooth texture, while apple butter is thicker and has chunks of apples in it.

Can I use honey as a substitute for apple jelly?

Yes, you can use honey as a substitute for apple jelly. Honey has a similar sweetness and can be used in the same recipes.

Can I use apple sauce as a substitute for apple jelly?

Yes, you can use apple sauce as a substitute for apple jelly. Apple sauce is made from cooked apples and has a similar texture to apple jelly.

However, apple sauce is not as sweet as apple jelly, so you may want to add a little bit of sugar to your recipe if you are using apple sauce as a substitute.

What’s the difference between jam and jelly?

Jam is made from fruit pulp and has a thicker texture. Jelly is made from fruit juice and has a smoother texture.


There are many substitutes for apple jelly, including marmalade, orange jam, honey, and apple sauce.

Each of these substitutes has a unique flavor that can be used to enhance your recipe.

So go and try out some of these substitutes in your next recipe!